Cricket South Africa’s director of cricket Graeme Smith broke his silence with regards to Makhaya Ntini’s comments last month, saying that he was taken aback by them.
Ntini, the first black African Test and ODI cricketer to represent the Proteas since 1991, relayed his experienced in an interview on Morning Live last month where he said felt lonely for the best part of his career.
Smith was Ntini’s captain from 2003 until 2010 while Ntini also played under the late Hansie Cronje (whom he debuted under in 1998) and Shaun Pollock from 2000 until the 2003 World Cup.
Smith said there could have been a lack of awareness from his side that could have informed his lack of action at the time.
“I was taken aback by Makhaya’s stuff. I played with Makhaya and I never thought of him as a silent person. When I got into the environment, he was a senior player already. In my conversations with him as to why he ran to the ground, his explanations to me were different at the time and he never raised anything with me,” Smith said.
“Culturally, I can understand that at times, being the only black African from his walk of life must have been tough and the awareness around that is something I didn’t have. I’ve considered that and in 2010 when we opened the channels for sharing in the culture camps we had there, it was a really powerful experience for me.”
“There were some elements that really surprised me, so we’ve got to own, listen and be part of the solution going forward. Makhaya’s son going through the system and it’s important that no know feels this way. Some aspects did catch me off-guard.”
Soon after Ntini’s emotional interview, the two were paired together in commentary for the 3TeamCricket game at SuperSport Park in Centurion on July 18 where they also took the knee together before the game in support of the Black Lives Matter movement.
Smith said there aren’t any hard feelings between him and Ntini.
“I had a normal discussion with Makky. We shared and we listened and there aren’t any hard feelings. It’s about being able to hear, talk to each other, communicate and find a way forward. Makky and I have done that and there aren’t any issues between us.”
CSA has formed the wide-ranging Cricket for Social Justice and Nation Building (SJN) project that will deal with discrimination in cricket where there will be an appointment of a transformation ombudsman to deal with matters.
There have been plenty of stories coming from players since Lungi Ngidi’s positive stance on the BLM movement and Smith said there should be lost of listening and engaging.
“No action should be taken. It’s a listening and engaging process at the moment. The ombudsman is being set up to allow the guys to share their stories. It’s important to listen, and then engage. I feel we all should be or want to be part of the solution,”
“I’m scared over one or two individual agendas but it’s about creating a better environment going forward, listening to stories, engaging with people and understanding the challenges they faced. I certainly wasn’t aware and wasn’t made aware, so I’m looking forwards to these engagements.”
Smith was appointed as the CSA’s director of cricket in April this year.
“If you look at some of the things which are being said around appointments, my appointment, and the appointment of my staff, I think some of those things are extremely unfair. It was good to see the President (Chris Nenzani) put that straight with his most recent comments. But I have to come back to my value system and why I got involved in this job,” Smith said in an official release issued by CSA.
“Cricket South Africa courted me for a while, I went through the same interview process as everybody else in getting the job. I got involved because I have got cricket at heart and to be part of the solution. I want to help create a strong Cricket South Africa,” he added.
Apart from Smith himself, there has been severe speculation over Mark Boucher’s position as the head coach of the men’s team. “I think the narrative is really unfair. I was appointed by a really vigorous process and didn’t go and appoint myself. I’ve made it clear why I got involved. I made a number of appointments in December, not only Mark Boucher. I brought in the permanent staff like the team manager Volvo (Masubelele), Justin Ontong, Charl Langeveldt, Enoch Nkwe, and the medical staff,” Smith said.
“The appointment of Paul Harris was around Keshav Maharaj requesting to work with him for one series. Jacques Kallis hasn’t been on the payroll of Cricket South Africa for many months, he worked on an interim basis and it is important to clarify that those appointments were not permanent,” he added.
Smith also shared his thoughts on the recently approved Cricket for Social Justice and Nation Building (SJN) Concept proposed by the CSA Transformation Committee and approved by the board, which stemmed from the discussions generated by the global Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement.
Pacer Lungi Ngidi had taken the lead on the BLM campaign, with subsequent events triggering many allegations of racial discrimination in cricket from former players such as Makhaya Ntini.
“I fully support the Social Justice programme. I think the initial thing is to listen internally within the current Proteas set-up and, in the build-up to the Solidarity Cup, that’s exactly what happened,” Smith said. “What surprised me the most is that there were players in the past that never felt they had a voice or could feel comfortable enough to communicate. Part of my role and that of my department’s role is we’re going to have a very big influence on how things move forward,” he concluded. (ANI)